Case Studies: Wake Electric

Wake Electric Membership Corporation in Wake Forest, N.C. is a rural electric cooperative that provides energy and related services to more than 34,500 residential and commercial members in 7 North Carolina counties. Wake Electric represents 55,000 Heating Ventilation Air Conditioning (HVAC) units, water heaters and pool pumps, which are high energy consuming devices.

Today, Wake Electric purchases power from North Carolina ElectricMembership Corporation that in turn buys power from Duke Energy and Progress Energy. Wake Electric sought to create a more efficient and environmentally responsible electrical grid. The goal was to improve demand forecasting and manage peak loads while ensuring their members were able to control their comfort level and save on energy bills. The need for a real-time Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) system, integrated control software, the ability to meet renewable legislation requirements and backhaul led them to implement Consert’s Energy Management Solution and test its effectiveness in a pilot program.

Working closely with Consert, Wake Electric conducted this pilot program with 100 members in its service area over an eight-month period. The Consert Energy Management Solution is based on a wireless smart grid technology which allows members to conserve energy and offer it back to Wake Electric as a source of capacity and energy reserves. Within two weeks of announcing the pilot program, Wake Electric received responses from more than 200 members willing to participate.

Wake Electric saw the need to look at new technologies that could manage loads more effectively, especially in periods of peak demand. It sought sources of capacity to provide flexibility and reliability, in addition to helping improve its planning needs.

The cooperative also needed to put practices in place to comply with North Carolina’s Renewable Energy Portfolio Standards legislation which mandates it must meet 10% of its energy needs through renewable energy resources or energy efficiency measure.

An assessment of its existing energy landscape and member needs led Wake Electric to seek a comprehensive smart grid solution.

Wake Electric knew its members’ needs were simple—keep the lights on, keep rates low and keep providing excellent service. It saw the opportunity to meet these requests by moving beyond an AMI-only solution to a demand side management solution.


Pilot participant’s energy savings during the summer months of the pilot vs. the participant’s summer energy use in previous years (prior to the Consert installation). (Calculation based on an adjustment for outside air temperature.) Additionally, participants’ perceived savings was 20%. 2010 was an incredibly hot summer and usage increased for almost all WEMC members, but those using the Consert Solution had lower usage overall when compared to the rest of the membership.


Addressing Wake Electric’s Needs

Consert hosted a specialized operations center configured for evaluation purposes including a Customer Service Representative Utility Portal which gave Wake Electric a range of capabilities.

Interruptible Loads. Start, edit & stop control events. The ability to initiate control events to adjust member loads with real-time feedback allowed Wake Electric access to data to improve demand forecasting, outage and asset management. During the event, Wake Electric could manage Control Group energy usage to shed load for the duration of the event by powering down assigned devices or letting them drift to the maximum or minimum temperatures as assigned by the member. If members found the event interfering with their comfort, they could opt out at anytime using either the Opt Out button on their online member portal or by adjusting their thermostat.

Manage Members. Wake Electric was able to easily search for, edit and add member records. Members also could be activated and deactivated as needed.

Read Power Meters. By reading electric meters remotely in real-time, Wake Electric could generate reports showing current kWh values for individual and selected groups of meters based on its billing cycle.

Create Utility Reports. Generating reports through its portal, Wake Electric could summarize and gather detailed information about members, control events and device usage.

View System Load Profile. Wake Electric could view a graphical representation of system energy consumption incrementally over 24 hours projecting loads based on the analysis of previous days’ energy consumption and outside air temperature forecasts.

Smart Grid/AMI Features & Operational Benefits. During the pilot, Wake Electric was able to read meters more effectively and in real-time, collect and use data to increase reliability, present energy usage information to members and empower them to manage their energy consumption. Going forward, Consert will be able to integrate its database with Wake Electric’s billing software provided by National Information Solutions Cooperative (NISC).



Energy Usage Control Event

Wake Electric ran a control event capturing energy usage on two climatically comparable days. The first day served as a reference day and the second as a control day in which the Consert Energy Management Solution was demonstrated. By systematically adjusting pilot participants’ devices to power on or off within the approved parameters each participant had set, Consert was able to demonstrate an energy reduction of 38.71% and savings of 73.04 kWh over a time period of 2 hours and 26 minutes. Consert also was able to account for and report 248 lbs. 3.38 oz. of carbon credits saved during the control event.